Apple Pie Ice Cream Fall Recipe | We are not Martha (2024)

This Apple Pie Ice Cream has all the elements of your favorite seasonal treat: apple pie filling, apple cider caramel, and pie crust cookies. It will convince you to keep your ice cream machine out all fall and winter long!

(This recipe for Apple Pie Ice Cream was originally published in November 2014, but has been updated in 2018).

There are some things about being an adult that are just no fun. For instance, no longer being able to stay up ridiculously late. Or having more than a couple glasses of wine in one sitting.

I mean, I can obviously still do these things, but not without wanting to die for precisely 24 hours after following the event. And then feeling like I wasted an entire day of my life lying in bed recovering. It’s just not fair.

My new biggest “being an adult stinks” realization is that I can’t eat spicy food the way I used to. And spicy food is pretty much my favorite thing in all the world. The whole world. Getting old is lame.

But I’m so, so thankful that I haven’t developed any intolerances to lactose thus far in my life (I’m knocking on a giant piece of wood and silently freaking out over the possibility). Because that means that I can enjoy ice cream to the fullest extent and not have to worry about a thing… Besides gaining a bunch of pounds.

I know "official ice cream season" is over (wah!), but I actually think I make the least amount of ice cream in the summer.

There are so many fall seasonal flavors I’m a fan of and I just can’t resist keeping my ice cream maker churning throughout the colder months. One of my very favorite fall flavors is that of apple pie. So, I turned it into an ice cream with this Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel and Pie Crust Cookies. This fed my ice cream and my apple obsession all at once.

Apple Pie Ice Cream with Cider Caramel Recipe

OK, let's get one thing straight before we start... This recipe has a lot of steps. A lot. But please don't be overwhelmed! The steps include:

• Apple Pie Ice Cream
• Apple Cider Caramel
• Pie Crust Cookies

I do share some shortcuts below, so be sure to check those out if you're not interested in making everything from scratch.

Also not that you can make the caramel and pie crust cookies ahead if you want. The caramel should last a couple weeks in the fridge and the cookies a couple days in an airtight container.

Also? All of the steps are totally worth it for this delicious goodness!!

How to Make Apple Pie Ice Cream

First things first... Make the apple pie ice cream! This requires a few steps... The first is basically making an apple pie filling (yum!).

In a medium saucepan, combine chopped apples, along with butter, flour, ¼ cup sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, water, and lemon juice.Cook over medium heat, stirring occasionally for about 4-6 minutes until the apples are slightly softened.

Remove from heat and spoon apple mixture into a bowl. Cover and place in fridge to chill while preparing the rest of the ice cream.

Now for the custard-base.

Heat milk and remaining ¾ cup sugar in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Stir constantly, until the mixture just reaches the point of simmer. Remove from heat.

Lightly whisk egg yolks in a separate medium bowl. Pour about half of the warm milk into the bowl with the egg yolks, whisking while you do so.Pour the egg/milk mixture back into the saucepan with the rest of the milk.Cook mixture over low heat, stirring constantly, until it thickens enough to coat the back of the spoon.

In a separate medium-sized bowl, pour the heavy cream. Strain the egg/milk mixture into the heavy cream, making sure to continue to whisk. Stir in the vanilla.Cover with plastic wrap and place in the fridge for at least 4 hours.

Once mixture has been sufficiently chilled, process in ice cream maker according to manufacturer’s directions.When the ice cream is almost done hardening, mix in the apple mixture and cider caramel, making sure to reserve some of the caramel to drizzle over the finished ice cream.

Scoop ice cream in airtight containers and place in the freezer for another 4+ hours, but ideally overnight.

How to Make Apple Cider Caramel

If you don't make the caramel ahead of time, you can make it while the ice cream base is chilling during the first round.

This caramel is a pretty basic recipe, but it includes stirring in cinnamon and a little bit of apple cider at the end. Which turns a delicious caramel into an "omg I want to eat you with a spoon" caramel.

In a medium saucepan, heat granulated sugar over medium heat. Stir frequently with a rubber spatula until sugar turns into a smooth amber-colored liquid.

Stir the butter into sugar. The mixture will bubble quite a bit. Stir for about 2 minutes, until the butter is completely melted.

Stir the cream into the mixture and let it come to a boil.

Remove the saucepan from the heat and stir in cinnamon, salt, and apple cider. Pour the mixture into an airtight container like a mason jar. Store in fridge until you’re ready to use.

How to Make Pie Crust Cookies

And now for the pie crust cookies, which are really the icing on top of the cake of this recipe.

I love making pie crust; it's almost therapeutic to me. For this recipe, you make a basic pie dough, let it chill and then roll it out, cut out whatever shapes you want, sprinkle with some cinnamon sugar, and bake.

Put flour, sugar, cinnamon, and salt in the bowl of a food processor, and pulse to combine.

Add small pieces of butter to the flour mixture. Process for about 10 seconds, until the butter resembles peas.

Slowly add ⅛ cup of the ice water to the mixture while continuing to process, just until the dough holds together. Take care not to over process. If more water is needed, slowly add remaining ⅛ cup.

Take dough from food processor, flatten on counter, wrap in plastic wrap, and chill for about an hour.

On a lightly floured surface, roll the pie crust dough into a large round, about ¼-inch thick. Cut dough into shapes of your choice and place them about ½-inch apart on a parchment paper-line cookie sheet.

Gently beat the egg in a small bowl and brush egg wash on top cookie dough. Sprinkle additional sugar or cinnamon over the top. Bake at 375 degrees for 10-12 minutes, until starting to turn golden brown.

I made little hearts, but apples would also be cute.

Recipe Shortcuts

If this recipe is overwhelming you, don't worry! There are quite a few shortcuts you can take. of course, the ice cream base part is pretty important, but I won't tell anyone if you take shortcuts on the caramel and pie crust cookies!

Here are my shortcut recommendations:

• Caramel sauce: You can buy jarred caramel sauce. It probably won't be apple cider caramel (unless you know a store that sells it... If so, please inform me!), but it will work just fine.
• Pie Crust Cookies: You can buy pre-made pie crust dough and simply cut your own shapes in it. Or you could even serve your apple pie ice cream with a different kind of store-bought cookie.

Heck, I suppose you could even buy store-bought vanilla ice cream, mix in store-bought caramel, and top with store-bought cookies. But I really recommend making at least the ice cream base from scratch!

Um, are we ready to serve our ice cream yet? Please?? OK, sure!

Top every dish of apple pie ice cream with a little extra drizzle of caramel and a pie crust cookie. I crumble one of the cookies over the top, too.

The results? You’ll kind of feel like you’re eating apple pie a’la mode. But even better if that's possible?

I'm actually not a big fan of apple pie a’la mode (I don't really have many weird food aversions, but for some reason, I just don’t want ice cream near my pie, thank you very much) and I was a gigantic fan of this dish of ice cream.

And then you'll need to thank your lucky stars that you’re not lactose intolerant. Life could be so, so much worse. Unless, of course, you are lactose intolerant.

And even then, I’m pretty sure there’s a pill you can take for that. Because who could resist what this ice cream is all about?

This apple pie ice cream really does have all the elements of an apple pie and truly tastes like one, too. How have I never made pie crust cookies before??

We’re officially in festive ice cream season and I couldn’t be more thrilled. Is it bad that I imagine a blizzard going on outside and while I'm snuggling up on the couch in front of the fireplace with a giant bowl of ice cream on my lap?

Because to me, that is the life. I’ll probably be wearing some type of long underwear, too.

Does that sound like heaven to anyone else?? Heaven could also be that same scenario, but with a jar of apple cider caramel in my lap instead of a bowl of ice cream. And a spoon.

Do you have a favorite seasonal ice cream?

For more fall dessert recipes, check out my Apple Cider Cookies with Caramel or my Pumpkin Ice Cream with Pistachio Swirl. I'm also dying to try these Apple Pie Overnight Oats from Baking You Happier!

📖 Recipe